To Repair or To Replace: How to Know When It’s Time for a New Appliance

Fri Aug 22 2025

Nothing lasts forever, especially when it comes to household appliances. One day, you might head to your washing machine, fridge, or oven, only to discover it’s not working the way it should. The big question is, should you pay for repairs or invest in a brand new appliance?

At Metro Appliances & More, we don’t offer appliance repair services, but we can help you make an informed decision about when it’s smarter to replace your appliance rather than sink money into repairs.

If you start having trouble with an appliance, there are a few important steps we recommend taking before deciding whether to repair or replace it. These steps can help you avoid unnecessary costs and ensure you’re making the most informed choice possible.

Step 1: Check Existing Warranties

Before you spend a dime on repairs, find out if your appliance is still covered by a manufacturer’s warranty, extended warranty, or even a protection plan from your credit card provider. Contact the manufacturer directly with your model and serial number to confirm coverage. You may be eligible for free or discounted repairs if your appliance is still within its warranty period.

Step 2: Price Out the Repairs

If your appliance is out of warranty, get a clear estimate from a reputable repair technician. Compare this to the cost of a new appliance with similar or better features. Remember to factor in potential delivery and installation fees for a replacement.

Step 3: Apply the 50% Rule

If the cost of repair is more than 50% of the cost of buying a new appliance, it’s almost always better to replace it. For example, if you’re facing an expensive washing machine repair or repairs to fridges that are several years old, you could be paying more in the long run to keep them running. Appliances that have already had major repairs are also more likely to break down again.

Step 4: Consider the Age of the Appliance

Every appliance has a lifespan. According to Consumer Reports, most last 8–10 years on average. If your fridge is already 7–8 years old or your washing machine is past the decade mark, investing in new appliances may make more sense than putting money into repairs. Older units can be harder to find parts for, and even if repaired, may still fail sooner rather than later.

Step 5: Factor in Energy Efficiency

Many older appliances, especially fridges, washers, and dryers, consume far more energy than newer models. Even if that 20-year-old dryer still works, it may be adding unnecessary dollars to your utility bill and taking longer to get the job done. Energy Star-certified new appliances use less water and electricity, saving you money over time.

Step 6: Evaluate Maintenance History

Not all breakdowns mean the end of an appliance. Some issues are caused by neglected maintenance, like clogged dryer vents or dirty fridge coils. Regular upkeep can extend an appliance’s lifespan, but once major components start failing, especially on older units, it’s generally time to start shopping for replacements.

If You Decide to Buy New, Find Experts You Can Trust

If you determine that a new appliance is the right choice, start by visiting a local appliance store you can trust, one with knowledgeable staff who can help you compare options, answer your questions, and guide you to the best fit for your home and budget.

Protect Your Purchase with a Warranty

When you buy from Metro Appliances & More, you can protect your investment with one of the most comprehensive extended care programs available from appliance stores near me. Our program:

Covers major component failure after the manufacturer’s warranty expires
Includes factory defect coverage
Offers day-one power surge protection
Covers food loss (for refrigerators and freezers)
Has no deductible or hidden fees
Features a no-lemon guarantee
Provides hassle-free service calls

If you don’t use the warranty within 5 years, you receive a full store credit toward another purchase. (See your sales associate for details.)

The Bottom Line

If you’re facing costly washing machine repair, frequent repairs to fridges, or ongoing issues with other appliances, it may be time to cut your losses. New appliances offer improved efficiency, performance, and peace of mind, especially when paired with an extended warranty from Metro Appliances & More.

At Metro Appliances & More, we carry a wide selection of refrigerators, laundry appliances, ranges, microwaves, outdoor grills, and more. Contact us or visit one of our appliance stores in Arkansas, Kansas, Missouri, or Oklahoma to explore in person, or browse our selection online.

FAQs About Repairing or Replacing Appliances

1. How do I know if my appliance is still under warranty?

Check your purchase paperwork, manufacturer website, or call the manufacturer directly with your model and serial number.

2. Is it worth repairing an appliance more than once?

If the appliance is older and has already needed major repairs, it may be more cost-effective to replace it rather than risk repeated breakdowns.

3. What should I look for in a replacement appliance?

Consider energy efficiency, features you’ll use, size, and warranty options to protect your investment.

4. How can I save money when buying a new appliance?

Look for outlet deals, rebates on energy-efficient models, and consider package deals if buying multiple appliances.